6 Best Substitutes For Yogurt In Baking

Don’t have enough yogurt for your baking needs? If yes, don’t be too quick in going to the store and buying yogurt. You might not know it but you probably have some yogurt substitutes lying around your kitchen.

The question now is, “Which ingredient can you use as an alternative to yogurt?”

That’s exactly what you are going to learn in this post. So, read on. Discover the 6 best substitutes for yogurt in baking.

Substitute For Yogurt In Baking

Sour cream

The most common known yogurt substitute is sour cream. In fact, you can use these two alternatively for food baking. So, you can also use yogurt if you don’t have sour cream and vice versa.

Description

Sour cream is a mixture of lactic acid culture and cream. Sometimes, gelatin or rennin are added to stabilize the cream. 

Around 20 percent of its content is made of fat. When you mix the cream with a lactic acid culture, the bacteria will thicken the mixture and later on produce a sour taste. Hence, the name, sour cream.

When you use sour cream for yogurt, the general rule is that you use the same amount of sour cream as you would use yogurt. You can use this rule not just in baking, but also in salad dressings, dips, and baked potatoes.

Sour cream products

• Hoosier Hill Farm Sour Cream Powder – this is an easy and quick way to have sour cream in your home in just a few minutes. In the package, you’ll get dehydrated sour cream. All you need to do is add 3 parts water to 5 parts of sour cream powder. 

You can buy it here on Amazon

• Barry Farm Sour Cream Powder – simply add ½ cup of this sour cream powder to ¼ cup of water. You can then instantly have your sour cream ready. This sour cream works beautifully in your baked good recipe.

You can buy it here on Amazon

---

Sour milk

Sour milk is achieved through the acidification of milk. When commercially prepared, sour milk is made through bacterial fermentation or by adding an acidic substance.

Description

If you don’t have sour milk, you can simply get one cup of regular milk. Add about one tablespoon of lemon juice to it. Mix well and wait for five minutes. You will see how the mixture would eventually slightly curdle. From there, you can add the sour milk in the same way you’ll use the yogurt according to the recipe.

Sour milk products

• Parmalat Whole Milk – this pure milk has a long shelf life, which makes it handy.

You can buy it here on Amazon

• Lucy’s lemon juice – serves as a great juice to create your sour milk at home. It’s fresh and versatile in use.

You can buy it here on Amazon

---

Buttermilk

Buttermilk is a type of cultured milk. It is made by fermenting dairy drinks. In the past, buttermilk was a common by-product produced when you churn butter out of cultured cream.

Description

Now, there are a few reasons why buttermilk is a good yogurt replacement. For one, buttermilk has that same natural tangy flavor and acidity level found in plain yogurt. 

Moreover, yogurt and buttermilk have the same effect on the consistency of your baked goods.

For this reason, you can use the same amount of buttermilk as how much yogurt your recipe calls for.

Buttermilk products

• Hoosier Hill Farm Buttermilk Powder – comes with pure dehydrated buttermilk. It’s a great choice if you’re making cakes, biscuits, and pancakes. You can also combine this buttermilk with baking soda and other dairy free alternative products.

You can buy it here on Amazon

• Judee’s Buttermilk Powder – this buttermilk powder is free of gluten, nuts, and GMO elements. 

You can buy it here on Amazon

---

Greek yogurt

When it comes to baking, regular yogurt is commonly used. Now, you might ask, “Can I use Greek yogurt substitute instead of regular yogurt?”

Yes, absolutely.

Description

The main difference between Greek and regular yogurt is the protein content and consistency. When you use regular dairy yogurt, your baked goods will be harder and tougher. 

On the other hand, using Greek yogurt substitutes will make your baked goods tender and moist just like when you use sour cream.

As you can see, there’s a difference between regular and Greek yogurt. For this reason, if you’re going to use Greek yogurt as a yogurt replacement, only use two-thirds of it plus ¼ water.

Greek yogurt products

• Chobani Greek Yogurt – this Greek yogurt comes with mixed berries that will make your recipe even more delicious.

You can buy it here on Amazon

• Dannon Greek Yogurt – a non-fat Greek yogurt with no added sweeteners and sugar.

You can buy it here on Amazon

---

Cream cheese

Cream cheese is made of cream and milk. It has a mild taste and soft consistency. To keep it intact, stabilizers are added such as carob bean gum or carrageenan.

Description

Now, cream cheese isn’t really the most ideal choice if you’re planning to substitute yogurt with it. However, since cream cheese is a common ingredient used in baking, you should be able to make it work.

You can use 1 cup of cream cheese for one cup of regular yogurt. Please note that cream cheese tastes cheesy and salty. So, keep that in mind as you substitute yogurt with it.

Cream cheese products

• Cultures for Health cream cheese – this is a starter culture that enables you to make cream cheese wherever and whenever you want. The pack comes with simple instructions to ensure you get to prepare cream cheese properly.

You can buy it here on Amazon

• Philadelphia Cream Cheese – this cream cheese brand is perhaps the most popular brand in the line of cream cheese. It comes with a rich, creamy taste, making it a great substitute for yogurt.

You can buy it here on Amazon

---

Cottage cheese

Cottage cheese is kind of similar to cream cheese. As a fresh cheese, cottage cheese comes with a slightly creamy and savory taste. 

Cottage cheese is known for its small curds, produced during the acidification process. There are different varieties of cottage cheese that exist today.

Description

When using cottage cheese for yogurt, use a 1:1 ratio. Please remember, though, that cottage cheese lacks the acidity that yogurt has. 

So, the effect of cottage cheese on your baked goods will not be the same with yogurt. Adjust your ingredients accordingly.

Cottage cheese product

• Breakstone cottage cheese – this cottage cheese comes with 2% milkfat, making it a low-fat option. If ordering online, be sure to choose the fastest shipping option to receive the item fresh. 

You can buy it here on Amazon

---

Choose the right substitute for yogurt

There are different yogurt substitutes that you can use. The list above is a great place to start your search.

Be sure to understand how every yogurt substitute has its own characteristics. This means that they will have various ways on how they will affect your recipe.  Not only that but you may also check your chosen product whether it is dairy free or not if an allergy is an issue for you.

Experiment as much as possible. You can also read more about this topic and see which yogurt substitutes would best fit your needs, taste, and preference.