9 Best Store Bought Alfredo Sauce

If you love eating Italian dishes such as creamy Alfredo pasta, the best way to achieve that authentic flavor is to add the best store-bought Alfredo sauce. Doing so will not only bring extra creaminess to your dish but more importantly, it will elevate the flavor.

ProductBrandNamePrice
McCormickMcCormick Creamy Garlic Alfredo Sauce Mix, 1.25 oz(Pack of 12)Check Price on Amazon
PregoPrego Pasta Sauce, Homestyle Alfredo Sauce, 22 Ounce Jar (Pack of 6)Check Price on Amazon
Simply OrganicSimply Organic Alfredo Sauce Mix, Certified Organic, Gluten-Free | 1.48 oz | Pack of 12Check Price on Amazon
BertolliBertolli Creamy Basil Alfredo Sauce, 15 OunceCheck Price on Amazon
PregoPrego Pasta Sauce, Alfredo Sauce With Roasted Garlic and Parmesan Cheese, 14.5 Ounce JarCheck Price on Amazon

* If you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. For more details, please visit our Privacy policy page.

The best thing about many store-bought Alfredo sauces is that they are versatile. Aside from the typical Alfredo pasta, you can also use them for enhancing the flavor and texture of other dishes such as white pizza, potato casserole, soups, cordon bleu and more.

As useful as these sauces are, it’s not easy to find the perfect Alfredo sauces. To help you out, we rounded up some of the best brands we have found.

9 Best Tasting Store-Bought Alfredo Sauces

There are dozens of store-bought sauces in the market, and choosing the best sauce can easily become overwhelming. We have rounded up some of the best brands we know to help you make a good choice.


Posts you might like

McCormick Creamy Garlic Alfredo Sauce

1. McCormick Creamy Garlic Alfredo Sauce Mix

This sauce is a perfect partner if you love preparing creamy and garlicky Alfredo pasta and other Alfredo-based dishes. The best thing about this Alfredo sauce mix is that it does not contain MSG and artificial flavors.

The McCormick Alfredo sauce is a blend of onion, garlic, Romano cheese and aged Parmesan cheese. They come together to make any dish creamier and packed with flavors. This sauce can easily add a twist or elevate your favorite pasta dish.

Pros:

  • No MSG
  • All-natural flavors
  • Easy-to-use powder mix
  • Made using natural herbs
  • Contains Romano cheese

Cons:

  • A bit on the expensive side

Buy it now on Amazon


Little Italy Bronx Alfredo Sauce

2. Little Italy Bronx Alfredo Sauce

This brand makes one of the best jarred sauces using fresh ingredients such as imported Italian tomatoes, fresh onion, fresh garlic, Parmigiano Reggiano cheese, extra virgin olive oil and sea salt. In fact, other users say that it far exceeds many brands in terms of flavor, thickness and quality.

We also love the versatility of this sauce. You can use it in making shrimp, chicken and fettuccine Alfredo and a variety of pasta and creamy dishes.

Pros:

  • Produced in a green facility
  • No preservatives
  • No sugar added
  • Packed with flavors according to many reviews

Cons:

  • Contains xanthan gum which may cause intestinal gas if you consume more than 15 grams per day

Buy it now on Amazon


Prego Homestyle Alfredo Sauce

3. Prego Homestyle Alfredo Sauce

Imagine having the ability to recreate fettuccine Alfredo, shrimp Alfredo and chicken Alfredo from your favorite restaurant but with half the time and effort. This homestyle Alfredo sauce can help you make that happen.

Made from a blend of Parmesan cheese, fresh cream and garlic, it offers a delicious authentic Italian flavor. Aside from that, this sauce mix also adds creaminess and body to your dish.

Pros:

  • Rich flavor
  • Easy to use
  • Extra creamy

Cons:

  • A bit high in sodium, 1/4 cup serving contains 17% of Daily Value (DV) for sodium

Buy it now on Amazon


Rao's Homemade Alfredo Sauce

4. Rao’s Homemade Alfredo Sauce 15 oz. Jarred

Rao’s is one of the popular brands that make delicious homemade jarred Alfredo sauce, and this product is no exception. Made of premium quality ingredients, this Alfredo sauce contains three kinds of cheese when most brands use only two.

Moreover, as the brand recreates a homemade taste, the creaminess and flavor of this Alfredo pasta sauce are spot on. Adding this Alfredo pasta sauce helps you achieve that rich taste and creaminess but with less hassle.

Pros:

  • Versatile creamy sauce
  • Rich and delicious taste
  • Made from fresh ingredients

Cons:

  • High in sodium, 1/4 cup serving contains 18% DV for sodium
  • Contains enzyme-modified egg yolk which some people are allergic to

Buy it now on Amazon


Simply Organic Gluten-Free Alfredo Sauce Mix

5. Simply Organic Gluten-Free Alfredo Sauce Mix

If you are one of those who prefer sauce mixes over jarred Alfredo sauce, then this product is a must-have in your pantry. It has the right proportion of each ingredient to make a good-tasting sauce for your recipe. What we like about this delicious sauce mix is that its garlic flavor is not over-powering.

Moreover, this Alfredo sauce is gluten-free which makes it a perfect choice for those who are allergic to products with gluten. It is also versatile and it makes an excellent addition to a wide variety of recipes that use chicken, potato or pasta.

It’s also worth mentioning that this product is completely organic. They only use seasonings that are grown at the source.

Pros:

  • Uses organic ingredients
  • Packed with flavor
  • Easy to mix

Cons:

  • No parmesan cheese

Buy it now on Amazon


Classico Creamy Alfredo Pasta Sauce

6. Classico Creamy Alfredo Pasta Sauce

This Alfredo sauce is a good pick if you want a reasonably-priced sauce. It is also a good choice for those who are looking for a gluten-free jarred Alfredo sauce.

Made using fresh cream, butter, and aged Parmesan cheese, you can expect it to be creamy, smooth and full of flavors. It also has a hint of black pepper which you may or may not like.

What’s more, is that this store-bought pasta sauce is low in calories. One serving which is 1/4 of a cut just contains 50 calories.

Pros:

  • Rich and creamy flavor
  • Ready to use with your pasta
  • Gluten-free

Cons:

  • One serving contains 17% DV for sodium

Buy it now on Amazon


Barilla Garlic Alfredo Sauce

7. Barilla Garlic Alfredo Sauce

Some people love their Alfredo pasta to have a hint of garlic taste while some don’t. If you are one of those who love garlic flavoring, then this product is a must-try.

With a blend of real cream, savory cheeses and garlic among others, this creamy Alfredo sauce gives your dish that smooth texture and garlicky taste. It best complements chicken and pasta dishes.

What we like most about this Alfredo sauce is that 1/4 of a cup serving only contains 14% DV for sodium. Many of the sauces we’ve seen contain higher than 15% of DV for sodium.

Pros:

  • Made from non-GMO ingredients
  • Creamy
  • Can be added to many dishes
  • Considerably low in sodium compared with other jarred sauces

Cons:

  • The hint of garlic is a bit overpowering for some people

Buy it now on Amazon


Bertolli Creamy Basil Alfredo Sauce

8. Bertolli Creamy Basil Alfredo Sauce

Bertolli is another renowned and established brand when it comes to Alfredo sauces. The Bertolli Alfredo sauces will not disappoint you as they are smooth and creamy and packed with flavors.

The generous amount of basil and aged Parmesan cheese in this Alfredo pasta sauce can spice up many Italian dishes where you would otherwise use these ingredients. Aside from the delightful flavor, adding the Bertolli Alfredo sauce could also give your dish that creamy texture.

Pros:

  • Easy to add to make a tasty dish
  • Contains basil which can greatly enhance any Italian dish
  • Excellent flavor

Cons:

  • Contains xanthan gum that may cause intestinal gas if you consume more than 15 grams per day

Buy it now on Amazon


Prego Roasted Garlic Alfredo Sauce

9. Prego Roasted Garlic Alfredo Sauce

Love the taste of roasted garlic on your pasta? If so, this homemade sauce can give you that taste with no extra amount of effort.

This Alfredo pasta sauce uses butter, cream and Parmesan cheese, giving you that bold and creamy flavor and texture. It goes well with linguine, spaghetti and fettuccine noodles. You can use it to make shrimp Alfredo, fettuccine Alfredo and many other dishes.

Pros:

  • Low in sodium
  • The garlic flavor is not overpowering
  • Creamy and smooth

Cons:

  • Contains xanthan gum that may cause intestinal gas if you consume more than 15 grams per day

Buy it now on Amazon


Factors to Consider when Buying Alfredo Sauce

When comparing store-bought Alfredo sauces, there are different factors that you need to consider to ensure that you are getting the best value for your money.

Type of Alfredo Sauce

If you will notice from the list of products we have, there are two major types of store-bought sauces: One is jarred and the other one is powder sauce mix.

Jarred Alfredo pasta sauces are generally ready to use. This means that there are no extra preparations needed to add the sauce to your dish. So if you have cooked pasta, you can simply add your favorite Alfredo sauce, mix well to distribute the sauce evenly and that’s it. So if you are always on the go or don’t have time for long food preparations, jarred sauces are a good choice for you.

Jarred Alfredo sauce

On the other hand, powder mixes require more preparation time because you need to mix the sauce powder with water, butter, cheese, milk and other ingredients of your choice. Preparation time to make the sauce can take between 10 and 25 minutes.

Alfredo sauce power mix

Aside from the preparation time, jarred sauces and mixes also differ in their shelf life. While jarred sauces save you time, they can go bad quickly. On the other hand, powder mixes have a very long shelf life.

Ingredients

The ingredients are also an important consideration when choosing the right Alfredo sauce. This is especially true if you have specific preferences such as only organic ingredients, gluten-free and low-sodium or low-calorie options.

The ingredients are listed on the package so it’s easy to check them. Generally, Alfredo pasta sauces contain different types of cheese such as Parmesan and Romano cheeses, butter and sometimes egg yolk. Other ingredients that could be present in a jarred sauce include canola oil, rice concentrate and heavy cream to give the sauce a creamy taste. For mixes, they may also contain garlic or onion powder, corn or potato starch, black pepper and other spices.

Organic ingredients

It goes without saying that before buying Alfredo sauce, make sure to check the label for any allergen or ingredients that may not suit your liking.

Moreover, keep an eye on the sodium content of the sauce you are buying. Many of them are high in sodium so if you are on a low-sodium diet, steer away from those products.

Calories Content

While Alfredo pasta sauces help you make delicious meals, some of them are high in calories. If you are on a strict diet, keep an eye for other Alfredo sauces with low-calorie content. The calorie content of the sauce is easily visible in the packaging.

Taste and Texture

Of course, everything is all about the taste and texture. The best store-bought Alfredo sauce is creamy, buttery and packed with flavors. But it’s difficult to judge the taste and texture unless you’ve actually tried the product.

So the best way to know if the sauce is really creamy and full of flavors is to check what others who have tried it have to say. Read reviews about the product you are buying especially if you are getting one big bulk.

FAQs

  1. What other dishes can I use Alfredo pasta sauces for?

    The delicious Alfredo sauce can be used in many recipes. Aside from pasta dishes, you could also use them in recipes that use cream or cheeses as they can enhance both flavor and texture.

  2. Are there artificial ingredients in Alfredo pasta sauces?

    When you are making your own Alfredo sauce, you can control the ingredients you use to make sure that there are no artificial ingredients. However, it's different when you are buying commercially prepared sauces. Some may contain artificial ingredients such as the xanthan gum that may cause intestinal gas.

  3. Which is the best, jarred or sauce mix?

    It depends on what feature matters to you. Do you want a ready-to-use sauce, or do you want a sauce that you can store for a long time?

    Jarred sauces are the best choice if you want a fast and easy-to-prepare sauce. In like manner, choose sauce mixes if you want a sauce that can last for several months on your shelf.

  4. Is it safe for my pregnant wife to consume Alfredo sauce?

    Some Alfredo sauce in jars may contain uncooked yolk and other ingredients which may not be safe for a pregnant woman. So the key here is to not consume the sauce right out of the jar. You need to cook it with your pasta or other dishes to make sure that it is well cooked.

    Moreover, as these sauces are generally high in sodium and calories, these are not healthy for an expectant mother. You can consume but you cannot over-indulge.

Conclusion

The best store-bought Alfredo sauce can make your life easier and food tastier. There are many choices out there are. They may vary in type, ingredients, taste or texture.

While the sauces in our list are some of the best considering the different factors that you need to check, we have our top picks as well.

For the mix, our top pick is the McCormick Creamy Garlic Alfredo Sauce Mix. This mix uses premium quality ingredients and its many positive reviews can speak of its overall quality in terms of flavor and texture.

Be sure to check the rest of the sauces on our list to find the right one that suits your taste buds.

ProductBrandNamePrice
McCormickMcCormick Creamy Garlic Alfredo Sauce Mix, 1.25 oz(Pack of 12)Check Price on Amazon
PregoPrego Pasta Sauce, Homestyle Alfredo Sauce, 22 Ounce Jar (Pack of 6)Check Price on Amazon
Simply OrganicSimply Organic Alfredo Sauce Mix, Certified Organic, Gluten-Free | 1.48 oz | Pack of 12Check Price on Amazon
BertolliBertolli Creamy Basil Alfredo Sauce, 15 OunceCheck Price on Amazon
PregoPrego Pasta Sauce, Alfredo Sauce With Roasted Garlic and Parmesan Cheese, 14.5 Ounce JarCheck Price on Amazon

* If you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. For more details, please visit our Privacy policy page.